Blog/

How to write a 5-year ambient air monitoring network assessment

Antenna towers spaced along a dry hillside overlooking a green valley and farmland.

If your 5-year network assessment is sitting half-drafted in a shared drive because the "coverage" section keeps raising more questions than it answers, you're not alone. The regulation itself is short. 40 CFR 58.10 asks states and local agencies to review their monitoring network every five years and submit that review to EPA with the annual network plan. What it doesn't do is tell you how to demonstrate that your network still meets its objectives, especially in the square miles where you don't have a monitor.

What 40 CFR 58.10 is really asking for

Strip away the regulatory language and the assessment is really asking a handful of questions. Does your network still support the monitoring objectives in 40 CFR Part 58 Appendix D: population exposure, highest concentration, background, and transport? Are your SLAMS and NCore sites still sited correctly, or has land use around them shifted enough to matter? And, increasingly, can you show EPA that you've looked at whether communities without a monitor nearby are being adequately characterized, particularly in areas flagged for environmental justice concerns.

That last piece is where most draft assessments get thin. It's easy to pull five years of data from your existing stations and show trends are stable or declining. It's much harder to write a defensible paragraph about the forty miles between your two nearest PM2.5 monitors when you have no data from that stretch at all.

Where most assessments stall: the gap analysis

A gap analysis isn't a GIS exercise where you buffer your monitors by some arbitrary radius and call the rest "uncovered." Reviewers want to see that you've thought about spatial variability, not just distance. Does the terrain between two stations channel smoke or industrial plumes in a way neither site would catch? Is there a population center sitting in that gap that your siting criteria would normally flag for a monitor if you had the budget to add one?

The honest answer for most agencies is that you don't have ground truth for those gaps, and your assessment shouldn't pretend otherwise. What you can do is bring in a daily spatial dataset that shows where aerosol loading is tracking across your region, not just at your fixed points. A gridded aerosol optical depth product gives you a defensible way to say "here's what the space between our stations looks like on a given day," which is a very different statement than "we have no information here." That's the specific gap Air Quality Proxy's daily AOD raster was built to fill, as a between-monitor proxy rather than a monitor replacement, and it's worth a look if your current gap analysis section is just a buffered map and a shrug.

Write the gap analysis section to show your reasoning, not just your conclusion. If a gap exists and you're not recommending a new monitor there, say why: modeling ranks it as a lower priority, a mobile monitoring campaign already characterized the area, or the population density falls below your siting threshold. EPA reviewers have seen enough of these documents to spot a gap analysis that was written to check a box versus one that reflects real thinking.

Putting the sections together

A workable structure for the document itself runs roughly: network description and history, review against Appendix D objectives by pollutant, site-by-site evaluation (including any sites recommended for relocation or discontinuance, with the required technical justification), the gap analysis and environmental justice review, and your proposed changes with implementation timeline. Keep the site-by-site tables tight. Reviewers skim those. Save the narrative explanation for the sections where your reasoning needs to carry the most weight, which is almost always the gap analysis.

One more practical note: start the data pull early. Five years of monitor data plus whatever supplemental spatial information you're bringing in takes longer to assemble and QA than people expect, and the write-up itself is the easy part once the evidence is in front of you.

If you're staring down that gap analysis section with nothing but a buffer map, a daily aerosol raster over your region might be the fastest way to put something real behind it.

Get started

← Back to the blog